평점 만점의 리뷰가 11,000개 이상
8만 5천명 이상의 리뷰
10만명 이상의 포럼 멤버가 선호하는 에셋
유니티에서 모더레이팅하는 모든 에셋
1 - 10 / 127개 표시
사용자 리뷰
정렬 기준
I bought this package a long time ago, and recently thought about exploring it again. Unfortunately I was never able to make real use of it, and this probably won't change - mainly due to the lack of proper demo scenes. The screenshots and videos on the store page show some complete environments (with trees etc.), but the scenes included in the package are much less interesting. The developer instead sells the so-called "premium blueprints" separately, at a significant price, which add up to much more than the package itself. I find this a poor practice. I haven't seen any other asset developers handling demo scenes this way.
The main reason I originally bought the pack was for the castles and cathedrals, which were promoted on the developer's Facebook page with nice screenshots (part of the url: /535899169786851/photos/a.578462572197177.1073741831.535899169786851/1195732803803481/). However, without a demo scene, they are nearly as difficult to work with as if I had to build all of this from scratch. Surprisingly, the cathedral assets are not even shown on the store page screenshots, and there doesn't seem to be a separate blueprint for them either. The assets are definitely present in the package, and are mentioned multiple times in the release history, so I don't know why they've been forgotten.
As for the rest of the pack - there are a lot of useful props. The houses, however, look rather basic - they may be suitable for a top-down or RTS game, but probably not for an immersive RPG.
Overall, despite the pack being extensive, it's quite difficult to use. That's sad, since the sister Interior Kit is very good in comparison, contains multiple complete demo scenes, and looks generally better in my opinion.
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
1
1
퍼블리셔 답변:
8 months ago에 답변됨
Hi Adam27,
I don’t think that the 238 x 5 star ratings from many users are wrong in their rating of the package.
The Premium BLUEPRINTS was developed the same as DLC for Games.
You seem unhappy to have to pay for 100’s of hours of work that it is saving those that use them.
The 11 Premium BLUEPRINTS are all 5 star rated as well.
The paying customers are all happy.
Sorry it was not to your taste.
Cheers
Cobus
D
Wonderful Medieval structures
2 years ago
DolaStudio버전 1.9.8
This is a kit with literally thousands of pieces of high quality art !
I recommend.
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
1
0
퍼블리셔 답변:
2 years ago에 답변됨
Hi gostrafx,
Thanks for this review.
I was aiming to give the largest selection that I could.
I am glad that you like it :)
Cheers
Cobus
i
Mediocre
3 years ago
intohistory이전 버전 1.9.7
This asset can be summed up most simply in a short pros/cons list
Pros:
Extremely large quantity of content, including textures, models, and prefabs
Very performant, making it a viable pack to use with mobile games
Lots of available presets that make it easy to drag and drop structures and props into the scene
Cons:
Very low quality textures that are reminiscent of decade-old games like Oblivion. Definitely not fit for games going for any level of realism
The way the two kits are broken up (interior and exterior) makes it awkward trying to add interiors to structures.
Based on their responses to other negative reviews, the publisher is not professional
Overall: if you're working on a mobile project or a project going for a late 2000's visual style this pack will work very well for you. If you're using HDRP or going for any level of realism, then some of the props might be acceptable, but the majority will not be
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
3
2
퍼블리셔 답변:
3 years ago에 답변됨
Hi intohistory,
Thanks for the review.
The package is exactly as advertised and I provide a few FREE test packages for anyone to take for a test drive so that they can risk-free buy the larger packages.
Many users are using the 3DForge assets in HDRP projects using the built-in Unity Conversion tools with 100% success. From the results they are getting, I think they will differ from your opinion.
They are all complimentary that they can place many many assets without a performance hit because of the lower poly, atlas texturing and clever use of textures.
If you care to look at the Premium BLUEPRINTS you will further see what great output can be achieved with this and other 3DForge packages.
Please do come to the 3DForge Discord and look at the results from projects of other publishers and you might actually change your mind.
I would never want a user to spend the time to build a game and see that my assets is super non-performant and regret using them.
If you scan through other reviews, you will see that most users own most if not all of my projects for that very reason.
They can get a consistent look & feel at a high-performance end product.
On a side note:
Strange that you would without knowing and dealing with me choose to insult me about my level of professionalism.
Cheers
Cobus
Purchased the kit along with the Medieval Villages 1 not realizing that the kit is not immediately compatible with URP. I have converted all materials to URP/Lit, but it took some time. If your project is URP, you need to be aware of this.
Once converted, the quality of the assets is great. Very good work!
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
3
0
퍼블리셔 답변:
4 years ago에 답변됨
Hi igoapp,
Thanks for the positive feedback.
Even though the package does not come with URP or HDRP files out the box, the built-in Unity Conversion tools does a good job and can provide that.
That is why 3DForge sticks to normal standard shaders so that users that want to, can then customize it with the least amount of obstacles.
Thanks for giving it a go and then come and give a 5 STAR review, it is much appreciated.
Hope this contributes in a positive way in building your dream and project.
*Might not be URP compatible out the box, but is though through a small task
**Changing the review title would be great :)
Cheers
Cobus
J
Stunning
4 years ago
JasonMHirst이전 버전 1.9.6
Will be duplicating my review as I purchased this item as part of the Medieval Village Kit Bundle.
In short, an unbelievablely beautiful collection of just about everything you could need to create scenes for Taverns & Inns, Magic Shops, Town Halls, Guild Halls, Blacksmith Forges, General Stores, Jeweler Shops, Potion Shops, Herbalist, Banks, Armorer, Fletcher, Stables, Keeps, Barns, Store Rooms and more.
Fantastic collection, everything snaps together, is to a proportonate scale, and looks so good.
Few people have posted about the quality which I simply have to disagree with, with some fine tuning of light, this kit is beautiful!!
Author is genuinely commited to his craft, keeps pumping out quality assets and gives ideas with his free PBs to compliment what's on offer in this kit.
100% recommendation from me.
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
3
0
퍼블리셔 답변:
4 years ago에 답변됨
Hi JasonMHirston,
Thank you so much for this great review.
It is what any publisher that cares would love to read about his work that he passionately created, knowing that he contributed to someone else's dreams or hobby creating what they enjoy doing.
The Medieval Village Kit Bundle is the best way to get anyone started and own the two main Flagship Packages.
Thanks for your support in buying 3DForge assets.
Cheers
Cobus
Everything is amazing ;
- Tons of prefabs, from small pieces to complex assemblies you can drop in your scene directly.
- Very optimized meshes (low poly count), optimized textures atlases / UVs and materials.
- Very clean repertory. You don't have to spend a day organizing folders into your project like with most assets. Each asset follow naming conventions, inside a carefully thought folder hierarchy. You'll find what you're looking for without headaches.
- UVs are very clean ; it's a bliss if you want to customize textures / materials (like really, it was a drag and drop to/from Substance painter to customize a whole set of items)
I'm surprising myself even "customizing" the layout of other creators buildings exteriors / interiors by adding terraces, wall pans, beams, etc.. I always find pieces that match the shape / feeling / look of other assets, like a toolkit.
Author is very nice and quick to reply, its discord community is nice too,
I very highly recommend all 3D forge assets !
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
2
1
퍼블리셔 답변:
4 years ago에 답변됨
Hi Meishin,
Thanks you very much for the support in buying 3DForge assets.
My goal is to make sure that those that buy and use my Assets does so with a smile.
I always want the customer to feel like they got the good end of the deal.
You have mentioned some great features that are all important when using Assets and building game.
Happy Game Building :)
Cheers
Cobus
m
Works at a distance, not for modern stuff.
4 years ago
mechanimal1이전 버전 1.6.1
This is not a modern asset. It really is good for fast dev and prototyping. There is nothing about this asset that makes it work beyond playstation 3 days. Its pretty obvious that is will work with mobile, but it is also not interesting as many people own this. It is very recognizable. Not an interesting asset. 3 stars is for prototyping.
* Please backup your projects. That is a discipline. This is a requirement of development.
*The author has not asked me for a review. -Mech
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
1
1
퍼블리셔 답변:
4 years ago에 답변됨
Hi mechanimal1,
Thanks for the review :)
Many others have found it a perfect balance between look at feel and level of detail. I have had many comments of how it looks like a Set of Skyrim assets.
All the screenshots are taken and not photoshopped, so if what you see is what you get.
I, through all the package that I produce and sell, try to hit the balance between looks and final performance that you will get. I would not want to to have endless problems during develpoment of trying to manage shaders and funny tricks to get performance out of nice large villages and scenes and having my assets be the bottleneck and you not come back for more.
Most of the users come and purchase all my assets including gobbling up all the Premium BLUEPRINTS that publish for this very same reason, balance. Because I use Unity Standard features, those that want to can take it further if they have the skill and time to squeeze out their own personal flavour end result.
My assets are being used successful on Desktop as well as Mobile, with environment being able to be large and not have load times entering buildings, but rather seamless adventuring and game play.
I also have FREE packages that are samples so that anyone can check them out and risk free buy knowing what they going to get.
I completely understand that what I sell will not be to everyones taste, that is what makes the UAS great, you can browse and choose what you need for your project.
The 330 X 5 STAR reviews I would think dicate the overwhelping majority found what they were looking for. Having ones products in many published game products is a aim that any publisher would wear as a badge of success.
Thanks
Cobus
These are wonderful kits and blue prints.
I recommend them and have purchased all of them from this publisher.
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
1
0
퍼블리셔 답변:
3 years ago에 답변됨
Hi SuperDK7,
Yup, this kit is packed to the brim and then you can add more ready-to-use contents with the Premium BLUEPRINTS.
Thanks for your support in buying 3DForge Assets.
Cheers
Cobus
These exterior assets are really wonderful! The exteriors are detailed and of very high quality. There is a huge variety of components to construct your own buildings, the possibilities are literally endless. If you don't have the time or ability to build your own, the author distributes "blueprint" assets that do just that, and these two look amazing.
I'm using these in an HDRP project, and all I had to do was use the building in Unity function to convert materials to HDRP. There are a few collider mesh materials that don't convert, but these can safely be removed without any impact. Also be aware that if you want to animate parts of the building, you'll need to uncheck the "static" box!
In addition to the great assets, you get a very, very supportive and communicative author, who has a very active Discord. With the asset and the support, you get yourself a perfect example of a really nice 3D model package for your Unity projects.
이 리뷰가 도움이 되었나요?
1
0
Quality assets
Over 11,000 five-star assets
Trusted
Rated by 85,000+ customers
Community support
Supported by 100,000+ forum members